The Monday-morning quarterbacking has begun: even before it stops raining, people are second-guessing whether Houston and other Harvey-hit parts of Texas and the Gulf Coast were "prepared."
Exactly how does one prepare for such an event?
It's harder in some places than others. Houston is a sprawling metropolis of 6.5 million people, lying no more than 125 feet above sea level, with an extensive network of bayous all through it and untold acres of impermeable pavement to concentrate the runoff. As I write this, the rain is slowing down, but Harvey is easily the wettest storm on record in the Lower 48.
I'm sure I can't be the only person who's been getting an uneasy feeling of "déjà vu all over again" (thanks, Yogi!) when listening to or reading about Harvey's devastation. We heard the same basic stories of inadequate infrastructure, inadequate shelter facilities, stretched-thin rescue services, and unequal impacts to richer and poorer communities (I'll give you one guess who's getting hit worse) during and after Hurricane Katrina in New Orleans, and Hurricane Sandy in New York/New Jersey.
CAN a city prepare adequately? While it's politically difficult to justify expensive improvements to infrastructure or seemingly-needless restrictions on development in floodplains when conditions are calm, it is true that many cities could and should do more. For an idea about some of the ways to prepare, here's a checklist for municipal planners, from the EPA (grab it while they're still allowed to mention the words "climate change"!).
Massive storms, floods, droughts, fires, and other disasters may be touted in the headlines as 100-year, 50-year, or even 1,000-year events. But seriously: How many years in a row can we have "100-year" events before it begins to dawn on even the slowest among us that things are changing?
It turns out that it actually is possible to plan, build, and prepare for even rather extreme disasters, but it takes forethought. It takes community acceptance that it's necessary.
It takes keeping our weather satellites in place. It takes governing officials who acknowledge the realities of our situation, and can't be subverted by special interests who'd rather take a short-sighted opportunity to make a buck, or by those who think all regulations are bad.
To any who, like Grover Norquist, want to make government small enough to drown it in a bathtub, I'd like to remind you that it's harder to make the case for that, when your bathtub's been washed away in the latest "100-year" flood. Of course, FEMA (the Federal Emergency Management Agency) is on this year's budget-cutting list. So maybe you should just kiss that bathtub goodbye.
IMAGES: I first found the YouTube video of interspersed "before" and "flooded" views of the Buffalo Bayou in Houston on BoingBoing (the article compiles several more before-and-after images that are quite startling). According to streetreporter, who posted it on YouTube, "The still images are from unknown people shared by a French twitter user. I only made the dissolve to show perspective, which is transformative."
Many thanks to Wikimedia, for the 2005 photo of the Hurricane Katrina flooding at the I-10/I-610 interchange in northwest New Orleans and Metairie, LA, an AP Photo/U.S. Coast Guard, Petty Officer 2nd Class Kyle Niemi. Equal thanks go to Slate and Mario Tama of Getty Images for the photo from Hurricane Sandy.
I also thank Abode Home Group's "Restoration" page for the Fire/Flood/Storm composite image.
Exactly how does one prepare for such an event?
It's harder in some places than others. Houston is a sprawling metropolis of 6.5 million people, lying no more than 125 feet above sea level, with an extensive network of bayous all through it and untold acres of impermeable pavement to concentrate the runoff. As I write this, the rain is slowing down, but Harvey is easily the wettest storm on record in the Lower 48.
 |
| Exactly 12 years ago: Hurricane Katrina flooded the I-10/I-610 interchange in northwest New Orleans and Metairie, LA. (Wikimedia/AP Photo/U.S. Coast Guard, Petty Officer 2nd Class Kyle Niemi) |
I'm sure I can't be the only person who's been getting an uneasy feeling of "déjà vu all over again" (thanks, Yogi!) when listening to or reading about Harvey's devastation. We heard the same basic stories of inadequate infrastructure, inadequate shelter facilities, stretched-thin rescue services, and unequal impacts to richer and poorer communities (I'll give you one guess who's getting hit worse) during and after Hurricane Katrina in New Orleans, and Hurricane Sandy in New York/New Jersey.
 |
| A washed-out bridge, and then some: Mantoloking, NJ, October 31, 2012, after Hurricane Sandy. (Mario Tama/Getty Images) |
Massive storms, floods, droughts, fires, and other disasters may be touted in the headlines as 100-year, 50-year, or even 1,000-year events. But seriously: How many years in a row can we have "100-year" events before it begins to dawn on even the slowest among us that things are changing?
It turns out that it actually is possible to plan, build, and prepare for even rather extreme disasters, but it takes forethought. It takes community acceptance that it's necessary.
It takes keeping our weather satellites in place. It takes governing officials who acknowledge the realities of our situation, and can't be subverted by special interests who'd rather take a short-sighted opportunity to make a buck, or by those who think all regulations are bad.
To any who, like Grover Norquist, want to make government small enough to drown it in a bathtub, I'd like to remind you that it's harder to make the case for that, when your bathtub's been washed away in the latest "100-year" flood. Of course, FEMA (the Federal Emergency Management Agency) is on this year's budget-cutting list. So maybe you should just kiss that bathtub goodbye.
IMAGES: I first found the YouTube video of interspersed "before" and "flooded" views of the Buffalo Bayou in Houston on BoingBoing (the article compiles several more before-and-after images that are quite startling). According to streetreporter, who posted it on YouTube, "The still images are from unknown people shared by a French twitter user. I only made the dissolve to show perspective, which is transformative."
Many thanks to Wikimedia, for the 2005 photo of the Hurricane Katrina flooding at the I-10/I-610 interchange in northwest New Orleans and Metairie, LA, an AP Photo/U.S. Coast Guard, Petty Officer 2nd Class Kyle Niemi. Equal thanks go to Slate and Mario Tama of Getty Images for the photo from Hurricane Sandy.
I also thank Abode Home Group's "Restoration" page for the Fire/Flood/Storm composite image.
No comments:
Post a Comment